WSFNC
A train wreck in Eunice, Louisiana, Crowleys
neighboring city, in which no one was killed and no one injured produced
a free windfall for practically every citizen in town.
After the accident, the railroad company quickly
assessed the damages to nearby residential property and farm land
in the vicinity and settled with those who believed the company was
fair in their assessment. They were told later by a Federal judge
that even though they had no lawyers representing them they had to
pay 20 percent of their settlement proceeds to the trial lawyers.
Such reasoning escapes me but then I am not a lawyer.
Union Pacific Railroad settled a class action law suit
for $65 million dollars. It was their only recourse because crazy
run away juries might have awarded billions of dollars in damages
and that could have made the company go bankrupt.
It was reported that over 10,000 people put in claims
for damages or possible future unknown injuries. What injuries? No
one knows.
Can you imagine 10,000 people? This almost exceeds the
total population of the city.
One nearby farmer joked that there were more trial lawyers
in town hustling money than there were victims.
Did all of the $65 million go to the victims? No, of course
not: only a reported $33 million went to the so called victims.
I started thinking and trying to figure out where the
rest of the money went. I thought, surely the benevolent trial lawyers
whose main interest was the health of the poor, misfortunate victims
didnt end up with all that money. But try as I might, I couldnt
account for the missing money any other way. Yep, the trial lawyers
got it less expenses.
Now most of the people in Eunice are honest, hard working
people and it amazed me that so many would file such claims. I like
to think that character, honesty and a sense of fair play would have
played a part in their refusal. And I am sure it did in some cases.
But there are obviously more WSFNC than I realized.
I hope it never happens in Crowley because I dont
want to put our people to the test but I would be willing to bet 10,000
of us would not file false, dishonest claims.
If my math is correct, and if the money was evenly divided (and I
dont think it was) each person filing claims would have gotten
$3,333.00. We will never know because the lawyers, to my knowledge,
didnt explain the basis upon which they determined who got what.
Friendships may have determined who got what so I am sure
the lucky ones hugged their friendly trial lawyer. When you think
back that Judas only got 30 pieces of silver, you have to realize
that $33 hundred is a lot of money to turn down and its not
only the WSFNC who took the money with their left hand
behind them and ran.
Coincidentally, the Eunice newspaper which carried water for the trial
lawyers and free loaders, reported the windfall with a front page
story where the editor happily pointed out that the $33 million, using
the theory that each dollar changes hands 7 times, would boost the
local economy by $231 million.
On the other side of the horn, companies or insurance
companies dont absorb damages for claims. Ultimately, if they
want to stay in business, they have to pass it on to the consumer
so that at the end of the day we all pay higher prices for goods or
insurance we buy. Over time I suspect that the $33 million will not
end up being a wind fall after all.
Interestingly, a column by Brent Vidrine in the
same issue posed the question whether or not money brings happiness.
There is a lot of wisdom in that column for one so young. I tend to
agree that money doesnt guarantee happiness.
Oh yes, WSFNC stands for Want
Something for Nothing Crowd.
Thats
my story and I am sticking to it.
Milo A. Nickel is the former President and COO
of Louisiana State Newspapers.